CLEAN INSIGHTS / Protection & climate

Zinc whiskers in data centers: detect, assess, act correctly

Published on .

They are thinner than a hair, grow unnoticed beneath the raised floor and can cause servers, switches and power supplies to fail: zinc whiskers. The US professional society ASHRAE describes them as the most common electrically conductive particles in data centers. This article explains where they come from, how to detect them and what to do if you suspect them.

Illustration: under a magnifying glass, fine zinc whiskers on a galvanized surface light up in the low-angle beam of a flashlight. An airflow carries broken-off filaments to a server rack.

What zinc whiskers are

Zinc whiskers are fine, electrically conductive filaments of zinc. They can grow spontaneously from zinc-plated metal surfaces, without any external trigger; many zinc-coated surfaces, however, never grow whiskers. According to NASA (Goddard Space Flight Center), the following is typical:

  • Length: usually a few millimeters or less. NASA documented whiskers longer than 2 mm on floor tiles; according to ASHRAE they can sometimes reach 1 to 2 mm.
  • Diameter: a few micrometers, i.e. thousandths of a millimeter.
  • Shape: straight or kinked filaments, sometimes nodules from which several filaments grow.
  • Growth: after an unpredictable incubation period of days to years, they usually grow less than 1 mm per year.
  • Conductivity: a whisker can carry several tens of milliamperes before it melts.

The phenomenon is not new. Zinc whiskers were already described in the 1940s. Exactly why they grow has still not been explained. A plausible explanation is that the metal relieves compressive stress in the thin zinc layer in this way.

Where they form

Zinc protects steel against rust. That is why it is found in many places in a data center:

  • Undersides of raised floor tiles: most frequently reported is the underside of tiles with zinc-plated sheet steel. NASA examined a tile type in which roughly 1 mm thick, electroplated zinc sheet steel was bonded to a wood-based core.
  • Substructure: pedestals and stringers of the raised floor.
  • Small parts and equipment: screws, nuts, washers, cabinets, enclosures and bus bars.
  • Other zinc-plated components in the room: for example zinc-plated barrier grilles, grids or sheets that separate areas.

From our practice: during a visual inspection, we have so far found zinc whiskers on a zinc-plated barrier grille between the aisle of the computer room air handlers (CRAH aisle) and the computer room. Where a finding needs to be confirmed, we commission a laboratory. The raised floor tiles in the data centers where we have worked, by contrast, had plastic edges and undersides made of thin aluminum sheet, so no zinc-plated surfaces. This shows that you should not only look beneath the floor, but at all zinc-plated parts in the airflow path.

The plating method is decisive. Zinc is applied either by electroplating or by hot-dip galvanizing. According to ASHRAE, whiskers can grow on both types of coating, but electroplated surfaces are far more susceptible.

Older installations are particularly affected. The floor documented by NASA was more than 20 years old. According to Network World (2004), tiles of this design were for the most part no longer being made even then. They may still be found in older data centers, however, and new equipment is often installed in existing rooms.

How whiskers lead to failures

As long as whiskers stay attached to the underside of a tile, they do no harm. They become dangerous once they break loose. NASA describes the chain of events as follows:

  1. Whiskers grow beneath the floor on zinc-plated tiles, pedestals and stringers.
  2. When tiles are lifted, moved or bumped, they break off. According to ASHRAE, pulling cables beneath the floor can also dislodge them.
  3. The air conditioning picks up the light filaments.
  4. They spread throughout the room via perforated tiles and air outlets.
  5. The fans of IT equipment draw them in, and they bridge closely spaced conductors.

This also means that work on the raised floor in particular, whether conversion, cabling or cleaning, can trigger a problem that had been dormant until then.

Possible damage

A whisker that touches two conductors causes a short circuit. How this shows depends on the available current. With small currents, the short circuit persists. If more current flows than the whisker can carry, it melts, leaving a brief, intermittent fault. According to ASHRAE, circuits from about 25 V upward are at risk: short circuits, arcing and signal interference up to complete failure are possible. A specialist from HP reported on a customer who lost dozens of power supplies after two air conditioning units were switched on at the same time (Network World, 2004).

What makes this tricky is that the faults appear random. A device fails, runs again after a restart, and the cause remains unclear. NASA reports that some previously "unexplained" failures were later traced back to zinc whiskers.

A well-known case from Canada shows the scale: at a geriatric care organization in Toronto, a cleaning company lifted the floor tiles in the data center in 2002. A few weeks later, servers began to fail, affecting motherboards and hard drives among other components. Until the cause was found, the IT team worked an average of around 40 hours of overtime per week. Replacing floor and ceiling tiles and a deep cleaning cost at least $100,000 (Network World, 2004).

Detecting zinc whiskers

To the naked eye, whiskers can hardly be distinguished from dust. There is, however, a simple first test that ASHRAE and NASA describe in similar ways:

  • Carefully lift a floor tile and inspect it outside the area with operating IT equipment, as NASA expressly stresses. Ideally choose a tile that has not been moved for a long time.
  • Stand the tile on edge (ASHRAE) or lay it metal side up (NASA), ideally in a darkened area.
  • Shine a flashlight across the underside at a low angle, at about 45° or almost parallel to the surface.
  • A dark background helps. The filaments are illuminated without being outshone by a bright surface behind them.
  • Small, glittering points or fine, protruding filaments may indicate whiskers.

An inconspicuous test does not rule out whiskers. Zinc whiskers can only be reliably confirmed in a laboratory. Samples are taken with conductive carbon adhesive tabs and examined under a scanning electron microscope (SEM). In its environmental requirements, IBM describes a specific procedure: collect dust from surfaces in 10 randomly selected areas of the data center on conductive adhesive tabs 1.5 cm in diameter. If the SEM examination shows no zinc whiskers, the data center is considered free of them.

What manufacturers require

ASHRAE Technical Committee 9.9, in which major IT manufacturers participate, and manufacturers such as IBM state in their requirements that data centers must be free of zinc whiskers. Zinc whiskers are therefore not a side issue, but part of the environmental conditions that manufacturers specify for operating their equipment. How particles are assessed overall is explained in our article on ISO Class 8 under ISO 14644-1.

What to do if you suspect or find zinc whiskers

A suspicion should not be ignored, but neither should it be tackled hastily. Any careless action can release more whiskers.

  • Leave the floor alone: only open tiles when necessary. Postpone cabling work beneath the floor where possible until the situation has been clarified.
  • Establish proof: document the visual inspection, take samples and have them confirmed in a laboratory.
  • Replace rather than coat: according to ASHRAE, remediation includes replacing the affected floor tiles and having the data center professionally cleaned. NASA points out that complete replacement of tiles, substructure or cabinets is often necessary. In our view, the same applies to grilles and other zinc-plated components in the airflow path. Painting over them is not a proven solution: according to NASA (Brusse/Sampson 2004), whiskers can grow through some coatings depending on their properties and thickness, and long-term tests are lacking; an HP expert reported that whiskers grew through epoxy coatings in tests. In addition, any work on the surface can dislodge more whiskers. For replacement parts, the manufacturer should confirm that they have no electroplated zinc surfaces.
  • Release nothing during removal: from our practice, we recommend screening off the work area with plastic sheeting beforehand and clarifying with the operator whether the airflow can be reduced at that point. Affected parts such as grilles are wrapped in plastic sheeting while still installed, if possible, and carried out of the room wrapped. Floor tiles are lifted one by one without bumping them. The affected component itself is neither vacuumed nor brushed, because nozzle, brush and suction release more filaments.
  • Clean the surroundings correctly: no compressed air, no blowing out, no dry sweeping. That spreads the filaments throughout the airflow path. Loose filaments are picked up with vacuum cleaners fitted with H14 HEPA filters, section by section, with the nozzle held clear and without brush contact. This is followed by damp wiping with lint-free cloths. Cleaning covers not only the floor void but also surfaces in the room on which whiskers may have settled.
  • Involve the air conditioning: agree with the operator how the airflow is controlled during the work and when filters should be changed.
  • Have IT equipment checked: whether whiskers have entered equipment is checked by the operator or the manufacturer. The inside of IT equipment is not part of room cleaning unless this has been expressly agreed.
  • Observe occupational safety: according to NASA, it is unclear whether inhaled zinc whiskers are harmful to health. Needle-shaped particles, however, are generally regarded as a particular burden on the lungs. NASA recommends consulting occupational safety experts on protective measures.

Prevention in new builds and modernization

Anyone planning a new raised floor or replacing tiles should ask the manufacturer: how are the tile underside and substructure coated, and is there proof that they are whisker-free? The professional debate has not been settled. Some consider hot-dip galvanized surfaces unproblematic. The NASA authors, however, report whiskers on floor tiles and support structures advertised as hot-dip galvanized and recommend caution with any zinc coating (Brusse/Sampson 2004). Written proof from the manufacturer provides clarity for your own case.

Our approach

When working on older raised floors, we look out for signs of zinc whiskers. If we notice anything when opening the floor, we stop work at that point and inform the operator. We then agree on the next steps together. Work is carried out section by section, with H14 HEPA vacuum cleaners and without compressed air. Our staff wear FFP3 respiratory protection, just as they do when removing dust on construction sites. How we clean raised floors in general is described in our article Cleaning raised floors in data centers.

Sources

  • J. Brusse, NASA Goddard Space Flight Center: "Zinc Whisker Awareness: Could Zinc Whiskers Be Impacting Your Electronics?", presentation, April 2, 2003.
  • J. Brusse, M. Sampson: "Zinc Whiskers: Hidden Cause of Equipment Failure", IEEE IT Professional, Nov./Dec. 2004, pp. 43–47.
  • NASA Goddard Space Flight Center, NEPP: Photo Gallery "Zinc Whiskers on Raised Floor Tiles" and Photo of the Month April 2003.
  • ASHRAE TC 9.9: Gaseous and Particulate Contamination Guidelines for Data Centers, whitepaper.
  • IBM: Gas and particulate exposure limits (environmental requirements, note on zinc whiskers).
  • B. Brown: "Testing your mettle: Zinc whiskers in the data center", Network World, November 1, 2004.
  • ISO 14644-1, Cleanrooms and associated controlled environments – Part 1: Classification of air cleanliness by particle concentration.

FOR YOUR PLANNING

Your checklist at a glance

  • How old is the raised floor, and which tiles and pedestals are installed?
  • Are tile undersides, substructure or barrier grilles electroplated with zinc?
  • Flashlight test carried out on several tiles and documented?
  • If suspected: adhesive samples taken and examined in a laboratory (SEM)?
  • Are there intermittent, unexplained failures, for example in power supplies?
  • Affected tiles and components replaced rather than painted over?
  • Work area screened off, parts removed wrapped?
  • Surroundings cleaned with H14 HEPA vacuums without brush contact and wiped damp, without compressed air?
  • Air conditioning and filter changes agreed with the operator?
  • For new builds: manufacturer's proof of the coating requested?

LET’S UNDERSTAND YOUR REQUIREMENTS

Let’s discuss
your IT cleaning.

Request a free consultation